Sacred Threads in a Societal Tapestry
Unraveling Family Dynamics through the Lens of Family and Civilization and the Holy Family
American sociologist Carle C. Zimmerman proposes three archetypal family structures in his 1947 work Family and Civilization1 : the trustee family, the domestic family, and the atomistic family. Zimmerman’s categorization of these archetypes serves as a framework for comprehending today’s diverse family dynamics and their potential implications for broader societal development. By closely examining the Holy Family through this lens, we unravel intricate layers of complexity in familial relationships and discern their profound impact on the trajectory of human civilization. The family is ordained by God, having been blessed by the Archangel Gabriel in Luke’s first chapter during the Annunciation to Mary.2 It is in this miraculous moment when the structure of Mary and Joseph’s marriage is sanctified into a new family structure ordained by God, where Christ becomes the central figure and guiding light to their bond as husband and wife.
1. Trustee Family – Love and Unity: The trustee family, characterized by strong intergenerational bonds and a focus on community welfare, is seen as conducive to societal stability. The Holy Family unfolds as a living embodiment of the trustee family archetype, where communal welfare and shared values take center stage. The profound love and unity among Jesus, Mary, and Joseph resonates deeply with the trustee family’s emphasis on collective well-being. Their unwavering dedication to a common purpose, particularly God’s divine plan, serves as a poignant illustration of the cohesive orientation of trustee families towards the betterment of the entire community. This model reflects interconnectedness and shared responsibilities, laying a robust foundation for societal stability by fostering a sense of belonging and mutual support. An example that further illustrates this notion can be found in the visitation of Mary to her cousin Elizabeth, as described in Luke 1:39-56. In this encounter, Mary, upon receiving the news of her own miraculous conception, rushes to share in the joy of Elizabeth, who is also pregnant with John the Baptist. This act of solidarity and shared celebration underscores the deep bonds of love and support within the extended family network. Mary’s selflessness in journeying to Elizabeth’s home, despite facing her own challenges, exemplifies the trustee family’s ethos of prioritizing communal welfare and shared joy. Through this simple yet profound gesture, Mary embodies the interconnectedness and mutual support that define trustee families, affirming their role in fostering societal stability and collective flourishing.
2. Domestic Family – Sacrifice and Service: The domestic family, emphasizing individualism and private life, represents a shift toward a more self-regarding society. Within the rich tapestry of the Holy Family’s narrative, the elements of the domestic family archetype come to life with striking clarity. Joseph, in his role as the head of the household, emerges as a paragon of sacrificial love and service aligned with God’s divine plan. His commitment to providing and protecting Mary and Jesus becomes an exemplary manifestation of the domestic family’s focus on individual roles and responsibilities within the household.3 Joseph’s protective role is depicted during the flight to Egypt and the journey to Bethlehem. In the face of adversity and danger from King Herod, Joseph courageously shielded Mary and Jesus from harm, embodying the sacrificial nature of familial love. His resolve to safeguard his family amidst uncertainty underscores the depth of his commitment to their well-being, reflecting the core values of the domestic family archetype.
Similarly, Mary, as the mother and wife in this domestic setting, plays a pivotal role in exemplifying the sacrificial nature of familial love. Mary’s support for Joseph– who is following the angel’s annunciations4 –and her nurturing care for Jesus illustrate the profound sacrifices made within the domestic family structure. Her presence alongside Jesus as he carried the Cross and was crucified exemplifies her commitment to her familial duties, but more importantly, to God’s divine will, even in the face of immense pain and sorrow.5 Moreover, the verse following the finding of Jesus in the temple, where “Jesus returned home and was obedient to his parents,” (Luke 2:48-52) highlights Jesus’ role as their son. Despite being the Son of God, Jesus humbly embraced his role within the domestic family unit, acknowledging the authority and guidance of Mary and Joseph. This act of obedience underscores the importance of familial bonds and the mutual respect and love that define the domestic family archetype.
3. Atomistic Family – Divine Purpose and Guidance: The atomistic family, marked by extreme individualism and weak family ties, is associated with the decline of civilizations.6 While the atomistic family structure is often associated with these traits, the Holy Family challenges this third and final archetype. By placing emphasis on divine purpose and guidance, conveyed through angelic messages to Joseph and Mary, coupled with Jesus’ unique role as the Savior, the narrative underscores the significance of seeking Divine guidance within the family unit. In this light, the Holy Family transcends individualistic tendencies by recognizing a higher purpose that guides and unifies their individual roles. This challenges the atomistic family model by showcasing the impact of Divine direction on familial cohesion, mitigating atomistic tendencies often linked with fragmentation, and promoting a shared commitment to a higher purpose that aligns with Zimmerman’s emphasis on the interconnectedness of societal and familial values.
In this landscape of the family unit laid before you, the Holy Family unfolds as a dynamic and multifaceted example that encapsulates elements from the trustee and domestic types, while challenging the hyper-individualism of the atomistic type, proposed by Zimmerman. The love and unity akin to the trustee family, the sacrifice and service reminiscent of the domestic family, along with the recognition of divine purpose and guidance which challenges the atomistic family model all contribute to a holistic understanding of family dynamics. This comprehension is particularly relevant in our contemporary world, where societal shifts and cultural transformations are prevalent, demanding a nuanced understanding of familial and societal dynamics.
Moreover, the Holy Family’s narrative does not exist in isolation; it resonates with the broader sociological framework presented by Zimmerman. The family structures he delineates find echoes in the sacred narrative, offering a layered exploration of how these archetypes manifest in a historical and spiritual context. The Holy Family, therefore, serves as a compelling example that not only enriches our comprehension of intricate relationships within families in our society today but also provides a timeless template for understanding the complexities inherent in familial and societal dynamics.
By intertwining the Holy Family’s narrative with Zimmerman’s sociological concepts, a profound understanding of familial relationships unfolds, extending beyond the confines of historical analysis. This holistic approach allows for a more comprehensive understanding of the intricate dynamics shaping familial structures and, by extension, influencing the course of future civilizations. As we continue to look to the Holy Family as the embodiment of our society’s families, we find a wellspring of inspiration and wisdom for navigating the multifaceted terrain of familial and societal relationships in our ever-evolving world. This exploration invites us to reflect not only on the historical and spiritual aspects but also on the timeless lessons that can inform our understanding of the intricate interplay between families.
Christian Alexandrou is the Ministry Services Manager at Communio.
1 Zimmerman, C. C. (1947). Family and Civilization. Open Road Media. http://books.google.ie/books?id=s0pcAwAAQBAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=Family+and+Civilization&hl=&cd=1&so urce=gbs_api
5 Garcia, Maria. (2013). At the Foot of the Cross. Our Faith And Mary Symposium. University Of Dayton. https://udayton.edu/imri/mary/_resources/docs–pdfs/t/taking–mary–into–our–homes–pdfs/at–the–foot–of%20–thecross.pdf
Why does marriage matter so much? We are, as Aristotle taught, social animals. We are hardwired to connect. That’s why our ties with others— family and friends—end up being so much more crucial to our welfare than things like the size of our bank account or the degree on our wall.
Couples who are on the fence about tying the knot may want to consider new research from the Institute for Family Studies. People who are married are happier than those who are not, based on Gallup surveys of more than 2.5 million U.S. adults collected between March 2020 and November 2023.