Key Takeaways
J.P. De Gance, founder and president of Communio, visited with bishops from America, Africa, Europe, Asia, and the South Pacific ahead of the Vatican’s October meeting on marriage and the family, convened by Pope Leo XIV on the 10-year anniversary of Amoris Laetitia.
Bishops on every continent described the same underlying problem: a worldview that places career success and material comfort at the center of life’s search for meaning, leaving marriage as an afterthought.
Communio’s briefing for American bishops found that 9 out of 10 Catholic priests ordained over the last two years grew up in a married family, and that 83% of Sunday Mass attendees in the U.S. grew up in an intact married family.
Since 1970, the annual marriage rate has shrunk by 65%. Sacramental marriage in the U.S. Catholic Church has dropped by as much as 82%, measured as marriages per 1,000 baptized Catholics.
The path forward starts in the pews: as many as 85 million Americans could attend Mass or worship this Sunday, and pastors can begin teaching the Christian vision of marriage and family immediately.
The Story: A Briefing for Bishops, and a Conversation Across Continents
Earlier this month, J.P. De Gance traveled to Rome to visit with bishops ahead of the Vatican’s October meeting on marriage and the family. Pope Leo XIV convened the gathering to mark ten years since Pope Francis published the apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia.
The meeting addressed five areas: the current state of the family, how young people are discovering the vocation of marriage, how the Church should accompany couples in the early years of marriage, how difficulties in married life are approached, and how the Christian family can be the subject of the Church’s mission.
Ahead of the meeting, Communio was asked to produce briefing materials for the American bishops attending. In a new piece published by the Institute for Family Studies on October 22, 2026, De Gance shares what that research found and what he heard from bishops around the world.
The bishops themselves expressed a clear desire: for the Church to go out to families rather than waiting for families to come to her. They also called for greater attention to marriage and family life ministry in local dioceses, including more family involvement in the formation of priests and seminarians.
The Core Finding: Marriage Is the Upstream Cause of the Faith Crisis
The data De Gance presents in the IFS piece makes a direct connection between the health of marriage and the health of the Church.
Communio’s briefing found that 9 out of 10 priests ordained in the last two years grew up in a married family. Looking beyond the sanctuary to the pews, Communio survey data shows that 83% of Sunday Mass attendees in the United States grew up in an intact married family. That pattern holds across every age group below 60.
The timeline matters too. The decline in priestly vocations and in Sunday Mass attendance followed the growth in the share of adults raised outside of marriage. Since 1970, the annual marriage rate has fallen by 65%. In the U.S. Catholic Church, sacramental marriage has dropped by as much as 82% when crudely calculated as a rate of marriages per 1,000 baptized Catholics.
From this, De Gance draws a conclusion that every pastor should weigh carefully: the marriage crisis is the efficient cause of the crisis in faith practice. There is no path to sustained renewal in the Church without the renewal of marriage in the pews.
The research also offers hope. The Devout Difference, a new IFS report, found that married men and women who most fully embrace the classic beliefs and practices of the faith enjoy the happiest marriages, and that churchgoing couples are the most likely to describe their marriages as stable and their intimate lives as satisfying. The teaching of the Church is not the problem. It is the solution the data keeps confirming.
The Counterintuitive Angle: The Crisis Is Being Exported, and the Window Is Still Open
Here is the detail from Rome that should give every Catholic leader pause.
De Gance noted that bishops from India and from Eastern Europe, speaking separately, shared the same sentiment with him. Young people in their countries are so focused on building income and living a materially rich life that marriage is no longer a priority. The European prelate grimaced as he explained that young people in his nation are motivated by a desire to live “the American dream.”
In other words, the worldview crisis is not confined to the United States. It travels. De Gance suggests that in places like Western Europe and the U.S., the marriage crisis could be described as being in Stage 3 or 4, while in other regions it is still in Stage 1 or 2.
That is sobering, but it is also an opening. In many places the damage is not yet done. And where it is advanced, the answer is the same: a renewal of worldview. Some have suggested adapting Christian teaching on marriage to the pressures of this moment. The evidence points the other way. The happiest and healthiest people are found where the historic Christian vision of marriage is embraced most fully.
The data from American parents shows the worldview at work. Nine in ten say it is important their children become financially independent and have a fulfilling career. Only one in five say it is important that their children marry. Brad Wilcox calls this the Midas Mindset. Pope John Paul II would have recognized it as consumerism, a disordered style of life in which people subordinate “being” to “having.”
What This Means for Your Parish
At Communio, the lesson from Rome is that a worldview cannot be changed by a document alone. It changes when pastors, parents, and parish communities decide to form people differently.
De Gance is encouraging about what is possible: changing a worldview is hard, but it is not intractable, and it is work that Catholic parents and pastors can do right now. Any pastor can begin by teaching the Christian vision of marriage and family from the pulpit. As many as 85 million Americans could be in the pews this Sunday. Renewal can start there.
Beyond the homily, the bishops in Rome called for more marriage and family life ministry, including helping young people learn to discern and live out a healthy marriage. That means parishes building a clear path: relationship skills for young adults, preparation for the sacrament of marriage, support for couples in their early years, and accompaniment through difficulty. It also means equipping parents, because the domestic church is where faith is first handed on.
Think about the parishioners who sit in your pews each week. Most of them grew up in an intact married family, and most of them are quietly navigating the same cultural pressures as everyone else. They are asking whether marriage is worth the sacrifice. The parish is the community best placed to answer.
Communio helps parishes build that answer into a real ministry strategy, with data, practical tools, and coaching.
Take the Next Step
Communio partners with Catholic parishes to build marriage and family ministry that renews the domestic church and forms parishioners for the sacrament of marriage.
► Read J.P. De Gance’s full article at the Institute for Family Studies → ifstudies.org
► Explore Communio’s resources for Catholic parishes → communio.org
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the Vatican’s October meeting on marriage and the family? Pope Leo XIV convened bishops from around the world in Rome on the 10-year anniversary of Pope Francis’s apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia. The meeting addressed five areas: the current state of the family, how young people discover the vocation of marriage, how the Church accompanies couples in the early years of marriage, how difficulties in married life are approached, and how the Christian family can be the subject of the Church’s mission.
What did Communio’s briefing for American bishops find? Communio found that 9 out of 10 Catholic priests ordained over the last two years grew up in a married family, and that 83% of Sunday Mass attendees in the U.S. grew up in an intact married family. Since 1970, the annual marriage rate has fallen 65%, and sacramental marriage in the U.S. Catholic Church has dropped by as much as 82% when measured as marriages per 1,000 baptized Catholics.
Why does De Gance call the marriage crisis a worldview crisis? Because the same pattern appears across cultures: a dominant view that places career success and material comfort at the center of life’s meaning. Research shows 9 in 10 American parents want their children to be financially independent with a fulfilling career, while only 1 in 5 say it is important that their children marry. Pope John Paul II described consumerism as a disordered style of life that subordinates “being” to “having.”
What did the bishops say about reaching families? Bishops expressed a desire for the Church to go out to families rather than waiting for families to come to her. They also called for local dioceses and parishes to increase their focus on marriage and family life ministry, and for more family involvement in the formation of priests and seminarians.
How can a parish begin renewing marriage right now? De Gance recommends starting with the pulpit: teaching the Christian vision of marriage and family plainly and consistently. From there, parishes can build a path that helps young people discern marriage, prepares couples for the sacrament, supports newlyweds, and accompanies families through difficulty. Communio helps parishes design and implement that strategy.
Credit: This post draws on “Renewing Marriage, Revitalizing the Faith: Insights from the Vatican Meeting” by J.P. De Gance, published by the Institute for Family Studies on October 22, 2026. Read the full article here.

Young Men Aren’t Drawn to Online Influencers for Fun. They Are Looking for a Model of Manhood No One Else Is Offering.
Researchers are debating why young men turn to the manosphere. Leonard Sax says boys need a positive model of manhood. Here is what it means for churches.

Should Families Split Up at Church for the Mission? A Georgia Pastor Says That Gets It Backwards.
A Georgia pastor argues in The Gospel Coalition that worshiping together as a family is Great Commission work. Here is what it means for your church.

The Church Is Shrinking. But the Christians Who Remain Have the Happiest Marriages in America.
A new IFS report finds 79% of churchgoing Catholics and 74% of churchgoing Protestants are very happily married, compared to 66% of non-religious spouses. The faith-family paradox is real and it’s good news for your church.